Meloni Seeks Pardon for Jeweler Who Killed Two Robbers

—

in

Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni has called for a presidential pardon for jeweler Mario Rotgero, who fatally shot two armed robbers during an attempted theft at his store in Naples five years ago. Speaking to the newspaper Corriere della Sera, Meloni confirmed her support for Justice Minister Carlo Nordio’s move to initiate the formal pardon process.

A Controversial Case

The 72-year-old Rotgero was sentenced to 14 years and 9 months in prison by Italy’s Supreme Court of Cassation — a final, binding verdict — for the killings. Surveillance footage showing him pursuing and shooting the robbers as they fled on foot went viral online, sparking national debate over self-defense, proportionality, and justice.

Meloni’s Defense of the Request

‘I asked the Minister of Justice to proceed with the pardon procedure for jeweler Mario Rotgero,’ Meloni stated. ‘We must call things by their name. No one disputes that the power to grant clemency rests solely with the President of the Republic — but that does not prevent the Justice Minister from formally launching the process.’

She emphasized the psychological and physiological impact of violent confrontation, noting: ‘When we’re under attack, our bodies and minds instantly shift into fight mode. Scientific literature clearly explains how adrenaline alters perception, sensation, and physical response.’

Meloni questioned the fairness of the sentence, asking: ‘Who is truly qualified to judge the pain, trauma, stress, and fear experienced by this man?’ She described the court’s punishment as ‘excessive’ — a view aligned with growing public and political sentiment in favor of leniency in cases involving perceived self-defense against violent crime.